Subaru Ascent vs Nissan Pathfinder vs GMC Acadia

2025 Subaru Ascent vs. Nissan Pathfinder vs. GMC Acadia: A Definitive Midsize SUV Showdown at Jim Keras Subaru

Discover the strengths of three prominent midsize SUVs competing in 2025, focusing particularly on why the 2025 Subaru Ascent shines brightest for families and adventure seekers across Memphis, Millington, and Cordova. Whether you’re navigating city streets in Jackson, embarking on weekend getaways from Dyersburg, or exploring off the beaten path near Marion, AR, this detailed analysis will guide you toward the best choice for spaciousness, safety, performance, and value.

Call us today at (901) 373-2700 or visit us at 2110 Covington Pike, Memphis, TN 38128 to experience the unbeatable 2025 Subaru Ascent firsthand.

Table of Contents

• Comprehensive Comparison Overview and Expert Recommendation
• Vehicle Introductions and Segment Roles
• Performance and Handling in Everyday and Adventure Contexts
• Exterior Styling and Presence on the Road
• Interior Space, Comfort, and Material Distinction
• Technology and Connectivity: Smart Features for Every Journey
• Advanced Safety Systems and Ratings Comparison
• Fuel Efficiency and Environmental Impact
• Daily Usability and Versatile Cargo Solutions
• Ownership Costs and Value Proposition
• Final Assessment and Why Jim Keras Subaru is Your Best Choice

Comprehensive Comparison Overview and Expert Recommendation

When selecting a midsize SUV for the Memphis metro area and neighboring communities like Bartlett, TN, and West Memphis, AR, families need versatility, reliability, and safety. The 2025 Subaru Ascent distinguishes itself through Subaru’s signature Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive, a highly efficient turbocharged boxer engine, and industry-leading safety technology. Competing against the 2025 Nissan Pathfinder and GMC Acadia, the Ascent offers an exceptional blend of performance, comfort, and standard features, making it an outstanding family hauler.

While the Nissan Pathfinder provides respectable towing and the GMC Acadia impresses with engine output and tech, neither matches the Subaru Ascent’s balance of value, AWD capability, and proven reliability. For drivers near Lakeland, Oakland, and Arlington, TN who prioritize robust safety ratings, all-weather confidence, and spacious interiors, the Subaru Ascent emerges as the clear choice.

Our recommendation: The 2025 Subaru Ascent offers the most balanced, capable, and safest package in this segment, suitable for diverse Tennessee and Arkansas roads and climates.

Vehicle Introductions and Segment Roles

2025 Subaru Ascent – Confident Capability Meets Family Versatility

As Subaru’s flagship SUV, the 2025 Ascent provides a unique combination of outdoor readiness and spacious luxury, perfectly tailored for families in Memphis, Cordova, and Jonesboro who demand year-round AWD performance. It replaces the former Tribeca with more refined power and an advanced safety suite, seating up to eight with flexible second-row options. The newly introduced Bronze Edition and Onyx Edition Touring trims add distinctive styling and upscale materials that distinguish it from the crowd.

2025 Nissan Pathfinder – Family Utility with a Traditional V6

The Nissan Pathfinder, refreshed with a strong 3.5-liter V6 and nine-speed automatic, targets family buyers seeking conventional power and straightforward technology in Dyersburg, Marion, and West Memphis. It emphasizes interior accessibility and features like power liftgate standard on upper trims but still trails competitors in torque delivery fluidity and all-wheel-drive standardization.

2025 GMC Acadia – Strong Performance and Modern Tech in a Premium SUV

GMC positions the Acadia between rugged and refined with a turbocharged 2.5-liter engine delivering robust horsepower and an advanced tech suite featuring a 15-inch touchscreen and available Super Cruise in higher trims. Its larger cargo and passenger volumes benefit families around Bartlett, Arlington, and Lakeland, providing a solid option for those prioritizing technology and engine output in a midsize SUV package.

Performance and Handling in Everyday and Adventure Contexts

Subaru Ascent’s Balanced Dynamic Performance

Powered by a 2.4-liter turbocharged boxer engine pumping out 260 horsepower and 277 lb-ft of torque, the Subaru Ascent delivers smooth, reliable acceleration coupled with Subaru’s renowned Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system for outstanding traction in diverse conditions. Its CVT transmission provides seamless power delivery and contributes to its respectable 0-60 mph time near 6.9 seconds, ideal for highway merging and urban traffic responsiveness throughout Memphis and surrounding areas.

The Ascent’s suspension is tuned to provide firm yet composed handling, instilling driver confidence during spirited drives across Lake County roads and occasional off-pavement excursions near Marion, AR. Steering response is precise, enabling agile maneuvering without sacrificing composure on highways and curving secondary routes.

Nissan Pathfinder’s Strong, Yet Less Refined V6 Experience

The Pathfinder’s naturally aspirated 3.5L V6 generates marginally higher peak horsepower (284 hp) but offers limited low-end torque compared to the Ascent’s turbocharged mill. Acceleration lags slightly with 0-60 mph times around 7.0 seconds, affecting overtakes and city driving responsiveness near West Memphis and Oak Ridge. Its front-wheel-drive base trims lack true AWD capability, a disadvantage for Tennessee drivers facing variable weather and terrain.

While the Rock Creek trim pushes off-road persona with a lifted suspension and all-terrain tires, the overall driving dynamics feel more compromised for daily comfort than the Ascent’s all-around capable setup.

GMC Acadia’s Potent Turbo Engine and Dynamic Tuning

With a robust 328-horsepower turbo inline-four delivering 326 lb-ft, the Acadia boasts the segment’s strongest engine output, translating to competitive 0-60 mph acceleration times of approximately 6.5 seconds. The eight-speed automatic shifts crisply, although steering feedback can feel disconnected from the road surface, lacking the communicative feel driving enthusiasts desire.

The AT4 variant provides off-road suspension tuning and all-terrain tire equipment, making it a versatile choice for occasional rugged driving near Millington or Oakland, but its higher price and complexity may not represent the best value for families focused on reliable daily use.

Exterior Styling and Presence on the Road

The 2025 Subaru Ascent maintains Subaru’s rugged-yet-refined aesthetic that resonates well with families in Lakeland and Arlington, combining robustness with sophistication. Newly introduced Bronze Edition adds exclusive bronze-accented wheels and trim, while Onyx Edition Touring delivers upscale black-out and chrome elements, clearly differentiating the Ascent in a crowded midsize SUV field.

The Nissan Pathfinder’s tried-and-true design incorporates aggressive lines with wide-opening rear doors to ease third-row access, appealing to buyers near Jonesboro seeking practicality. However, it presents a somewhat conservative look compared to the Subaru’s adventurous style.

Meanwhile, the GMC Acadia impresses with bold grille treatments and available 22-inch wheels on Denali trims, projecting a premium attitude suited to urban settings in Memphis and Bartlett. The AT4 trim elevates its rugged appeal with red tow hooks and off-road ready tires.

Interior Space, Comfort, and Material Distinction

The Subaru Ascent offers a roomy, functional cabin engineered for family practicality around Memphis and Blytheville. Its seating accommodates up to eight passengers, with flexible configurations including bench and captain’s chairs. Legroom measurements of 42.2 inches in front and 38.6 inches in the second row ensure comfortable long-distance travel, while the third row, though best for children, is adequately spacious for shorter trips.

Interior quality rises with trim levels, with the Onyx Edition Touring featuring Nappa leather and accent stitching for a premium feel rarely matched at this price point. The Ascent also provides up to six USB ports strategically placed across all three rows, maximizing connectivity on the go.

In comparison, the Nissan Pathfinder lags behind with less generous third-row legroom (28.0 inches) and fewer luxury touches. While it boasts bright, accessible interiors, material refinement is average, suitable for families who prioritize utility in West Memphis or Dyersburg.

The GMC Acadia excels in passenger and cargo volume, offering the largest third-row legroom of the three at 32.1 inches and ample cargo behind seats. Its Denali trim elevates luxury with leather-appointed seating, heated and ventilated seats, and an 11-inch digital instrument panel, boasting greater dimension but at a higher cost and weight penalty.

Technology and Connectivity: Smart Features for Every Journey

Subaru leads with a standard, large 11.6-inch vertical touchscreen outfitted with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, delivering intuitive access for families around Cordova and Oakland. The Ascent accommodates multiple device charging with up to six USB ports throughout the cabin, supporting busy households relying on their connectivity.

Optional Harman Kardon audio systems on higher trims produce immersive sound quality, and a Wi-Fi hotspot is available for on-the-go internet access. While the interface has room for refinement, its screen size and connectivity standardization beat the competition’s offerings.

The Nissan Pathfinder offers 8- to 9-inch touchscreens with smartphone integration, plus features like a premium Bose audio system on higher trims. However, its base display size and software lag slightly behind the Ascent’s modern approach.

GMC’s Acadia impresses with a massive 15-inch touchscreen featuring Google built-in apps and voice command, paired with an 11-inch digital instrument cluster. Its tech suite is among the most comprehensive here, including wireless charging and an optional 16-speaker Bose sound system, appealing to tech-savvy buyers from Lakeland to Jonesboro.

Advanced Safety Systems and Ratings Comparison

Safety is paramount for families in Memphis, Bartlett, and Blytheville, and the 2025 Subaru Ascent excels with a comprehensive safety package. Its EyeSight® Driver Assist technology, included standard on all trims, integrates front automatic emergency braking, lane keep assist, adaptive cruise control, blind-spot detection, rear cross-traffic alert, reverse automatic braking, and emergency stop assist. These features come standard at the entry-level Premium trim — a rarity in the segment.

Both the Ascent and Pathfinder hold 5-star overall NHTSA ratings and IIHS Top Safety Pick+ awards, reflecting Subaru’s leadership in occupant protection. While Nissan includes similar driver aids and offers the ProPILOT Assist system on higher trims, its all-wheel-drive is optional and some advanced features are not standard.

The GMC Acadia provides a strong suite of safety technologies, including automatic emergency braking, blind-zone steering assist, and available GM Super Cruise hands-free system. However, Subaru’s focus on active safety standardization and driver assistance coverage across all trims offers more accessible peace of mind to every buyer.

Fuel Efficiency and Environmental Impact

Subaru’s 2.4L turbo boxer engine, combined with the CVT and Symmetrical AWD, delivers estimated EPA ratings of 20 mpg city and 26 mpg highway for the Ascent Premium trim. Practical highway fuel economy can reach 28 mpg, benefiting drivers commuting around Memphis or traveling long distances from Jackson to Cordova.

The Nissan Pathfinder, with its naturally aspirated V6, manages similar city mileage but lags slightly on highway fuel efficiency, especially on AWD models, averaging roughly 20-21 mpg city and up to 27 mpg highway. Its larger engine inherently consumes more fuel under load.

GMC Acadia’s turbocharged engine boasts competitive fuel economy in the segment, offering between 19-20 mpg city and 24-27 mpg highway depending on drivetrain. However, higher horsepower and curb weight translate into slimmer real-world efficiency gains.

Daily Usability and Versatile Cargo Solutions

The Subaru Ascent prioritizes family convenience with approximately 17.8 cubic feet of cargo space behind the third row, expanding to 75.6 cubic feet with seats folded. While the third row is best suited for smaller passengers, the multiple seating configurations, including available captain’s chairs, make loading and unloading kids or gear in Memphis or Bartlett straightforward. The standard power-operated rear gate and multiple storage cubbies add to accessibility.

Though the GMC Acadia offers the largest cargo volume in the segment—up to 23 cubic feet behind the third row and 97.5 cu ft total—it comes at the expense of higher MSRP and increased curb weight, which can impact maneuverability in urban areas like Lakeland or Arlington.

The Nissan Pathfinder provides similar cargo flexibility but lags slightly in overall passenger volume and third-row comfort, making it a practical but less spacious alternative for families prioritizing maximum cargo.

Ownership Costs and Value Proposition

When evaluating ownership expenses between Memphis, Dyersburg, and West Memphis, the Subaru Ascent’s reputation for reliability significantly contributes to its lower long-term costs. Subaru’s 96% decade-long vehicle operation rate surpasses many competitors, reducing depreciation and maintenance surprises. The company does not include scheduled maintenance, but Subaru’s well-tuned drivetrain and robust AWD system require less frequent repairs compared to V6-powered rivals.

Both Nissan Pathfinder and GMC Acadia provide comparable warranty coverage (three years/36,000 miles basic and five years/60,000 miles powertrain), but Nissan sweetens ownership with included scheduled maintenance during the first two years. However, the Pathfinder’s naturally aspirated engine architecture can be less efficient, potentially leading to higher fuel costs.

The GMC Acadia’s premium trim options and turbocharged 2.5L engine bring greater initial purchase price and likely higher maintenance related to turbocharging complexity, but benefit from slightly better power delivery.

Additionally, at Jim Keras Subaru, we provide comprehensive service solutions, including our Schedule Service and Diagnostics platform and genuine components from our Find Subaru Parts department to keep your Ascent running like new.

Final Assessment and Why Jim Keras Subaru is Your Best Choice

So why does the 2025 Subaru Ascent emerge the definitive midsize SUV champion for drivers across Memphis, Oak Ridge, and Marion, AR?

• Proven AWD Performance: Subaru’s Symmetrical AWD is standard on every trim, providing impeccable all-weather traction unmatched by Nissan and GMC in base configurations.
• Safety Leadership: The Ascent’s comprehensive EyeSight® safety suite—including emergency stop assist—comes standard where others make it optional.
• Exceptional Value: Starting MSRP near $39,995 offers a friendly entry point with a longer track record of reliability and resale.
• Family-Centered Comfort: Spacious first and second-row seating, practical cargo solutions, and multiple USB ports accommodate the modern active lifestyle.
• Customization & Style: Newly added Bronze Edition and Onyx Edition Touring provide fresh, attractive choices blending ruggedness with upscale amenities.
• Dealer Excellence: At Jim Keras Subaru, 2110 Covington Pike, Memphis, TN 38128, you’re supported by experts who understand your needs with access to a wide selection of new models via our New Subaru Inventory and dependable used options at our Used Vehicle Inventory. Experience our friendly team by meeting them online at Meet our staff.

Schedule a test drive today at Jim Keras Subaru to see the 2025 Ascent’s refined capability in person, and ask about exclusive Current New Car Specials. Keeping your Subaru in top condition is simple with our Schedule Service and Diagnostics and genuine parts availability via Find Subaru Parts.

Additionally, find exciting sports-oriented models in our New Subaru WRX Inventory or electric options with the New Subaru Solterra Inventory.

Your next dependable, safe, and family-ready midsize SUV awaits at Jim Keras Subaru.

© 2025 Jim Keras Subaru